The problems confronting Balochistan

The grievances of the Baloch people are not without some genuine reasons.

The renowned columnist and bureaucrat Orya Maqbool Jan spent several years in Balochistan, serving at highly important administrative posts. In a scholarly lecture arranged by World Times delivered at the Superior University on Balochistan issue and he discussed the current turbulent situation prevailing in the province, along with its historical background. The important points of his lecture have been summarised below.

For centuries, the vast arid region of Balochistan has been regarded as an area inhabited by those frightened people who were driven out of their native lands and who took refuge here. The archaeological explorations in Mevgarh and Sandek suggest that people lived here in small towns thousands of years ago and used earthen pots and copper coins. At the time of the British arrival in this region, the areas of Yob, Loralai, Kila Saifullah, Pashin, Chaman and some parts of Quetta were inhabited by the Pukhtoons.On the other hand, southern areas like Mastung, Kalat, Makran, Lasbela, Khuzdar and Dadar were included in the state of Khan of Kalat who was a Pathan belonging to the Ahmadzai tribe, because, traditionally, Balochis like to offer their prayers behind Pathan imams. There were also some regions dominated by the Bugti and Mari Nawabs.

The English attempted to occupy this land by force but were met with severe resistance and about 300 of them were killed in Sibi. For the time being they withdrew and started making contacts with the Mari, Bugti and other tribal leaders in order to increase their influence in the region.

Like colonial exploiters we believe that it is our birth right to gain maximum benefit from their natural resources, while keeping them in abject poverty and backwardness.
 
Later, the English suffered a humiliating defeat in Afghanistan and retreated to Yob and nearby areas and in order to distance themselves from the Afghans, they drew the Durand Line. In the meantime, the vast state of Khan of Kalat was also firmly established and was mainly inhabited by Baloch and Barohi people. Bugtis and Maris are Balochis while Mengals and Raisanis are Barohis, whose language is of Dravidian origin and also has Persian, Arabic and Balochi words.Since the Barohis had joined the Baloch confederacy, they also began to call themselves Baloch people. In addition to about three million Balochis living in Balochistan, a much larger number of them live in Punjab, Sindh and Sistan (Iran). The condition of the Balochis living in Iran is much worse than that of the Balochis of our Balochistan. The Pathans living in this area have only one major Nawab known as Nawab Jogezai, while the Balochis have eight prominent Nawabs, such as Nawab Bugti, Nawab Mari and Nawab Mengal, etc. These Nawabs do not necessarily come to power by right of inheritance.

Sometimes, they are even elected or removed from office by the tribal elders. For centuries, the Balochis have been leading a very peaceful life under the umbrella of their own tribal system, governed by their own social and moral norms, customs and laws. For instance, if someone has Bugti blood in his veins, he will be equally respected among the Bugtis whether he is a landlord, barber, cobbler, blacksmith or singer.Similarly, due to their own excellent justice system, crime rate in most of their areas is almost zero. Their tribal chiefs are responsible for the law and order situation in their region and if a crime is committed in the domain of a tribal chief, he is expected to apprehend the criminal and hand him over to the government. Talk of the town is the talk of the court in this system. People hardly ever tell a lie and criminals are easily arrested. When a person is killed the members of his family are given the option to kill the murderer in revenge or to accept blood money in the form of goats and other such things.

By repeated military actions we may be able to occupy that land for a while, but we will not be able to win the hearts of its people.
In almost all the cases, the killer is forgiven and some blood money is accepted. Realising its importance, the English allowed this system to function till the partition of India.However, conditions began to change when Khan of Kalat decided to join Pakistan in 1948. Baloch nationalists say that he was forced to do so while his grandson wrote that when he asked his grandfather about his decision, he replied that in his dream, he had seen Prophet Muhammad who had urged him to join Pakistan, because it had been established in the name of Islam.

Some insurgency or resentment started shortly afterwards and the sense of deprivation and isolation among the Baloch people continued to increase. The creation of One Unit in the country added to their problems because for the solution of their problems these simple, poor and ignorant people had to travel to Lahore where they could not know what to do and whom to meet.

It is time to heal their wounds, alleviate their sufferings, reunite their thousands of missing persons with their families, address their genuine grievances and remove the root causes of their feelings of hatred and disgust.
Conditions deteriorated in Balochistan when Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto launched army action resulting in the deaths of thousands of Baloch people. However, there was a marked improvement in the situation in the subsequent years, when most of the people withdrew their support from the Baloch nationalists and defeated them in the general elections. The Baloch nationalists could never win a significant number of seats in the provincial assembly and people in general no longer had any hatred for the Punjabis. They even preferred Punjabi officers because they thought them to be more just and impartial while solving their disputes.Thus, there was a time when 22 out of 26 districts of the province had Punjabi Deputy Commissioners, who enjoyed full trust of the people. But everything changed with Musharraf’s military operation and the murder of Nawab Akbar Bugti, which shocked and outraged the Baloch people and aggravated their feelings of hatred and deprivation.

The grievances of the Baloch people are not without some genuine reasons. The fact is that they have always been deliberately ignored and our attitude towards them has been that of colonial masters. There was a time when we considered the Bengalis to be inferior human beings, worthy of contempt and humiliation.

Today, our approach towards the Balochis is also the same. Like colonial exploiters we believe that it is our birth right to gain maximum benefit from their natural resources, while keeping them in abject poverty and backwardness. The Sui Gas discovered in the early 50s could not reach Quetta till the early 80s.

The first factory for making fertilizers from gas was set up not in Balochistan but in Meerpur Mathelo in Sindh. Similarly, all the marble and coal got from Balochistan is brought to the factories working in other provinces. In 1992, the total development budget for the province was only 1.23 billion rupees.

We have created the myth that the Baloch tribal chiefs are against the building of roads and schools. But the fact is that Nawab Akbar Bugti and Nawab Mari themselves encouraged the opening of schools in Sui and Kohlu. They never resisted the building of roads and reopening of the blocked roads. While all sorts of false and fictitious tales are told about Baloch tribal chiefs, nothing is said about the obnoxious activities of Punjabi Chaudhris and Waderas.

Musharraf was attacked twice in Rawalpindi, but on neither of these occasions, was the whole city surrounded by the security forces. However, when he was attacked in Kohlu, the whole area was cordoned off to find out the attackers. Such injustices and double standards are bound to infuriate the Balochis. There was a time when only three levies officials were sufficient to guard the whole Sui Gas Plant but now, even thousands of security forces are unable to do so because they no longer enjoy the trust and co-operation of the local people.

When Musharraf launched military operation in the province he claimed that he wanted to establish the writ of the government. But he forgot that instead of establishing the writ of the government, good rulers always try to establish the writ of justice.

The Balochis have some genuine reasons for opposing the Gwadar Port project. Lahore Development Authority (LDA) and Karachi Development Authority (KDA) are working under provincial governments but Gwadar Development Authority is working under the Federal government, because it is argued that the Balochis are unskilled and illiterate and are unable to do anything. If they do not have the technical skill, they should be trained, instead of being sidelined and replaced by other people, because no one is a born expert of anything.

Moreover, all the important politicians of the country and members of the civil and military bureaucracy have bought plots in Gwadar at a much cheaper rate. In fact, the whole property mafia of the country has reached Gwadar urging the people to buy the lands. Thus, the impression is that all the people should go there and take part in the looting and plundering. When their lands are being grabbed and sold out at nominal rates and when their resources are being ruthlessly exploited, how can they remain silent?

When the Chief Minister of Punjab goes to Quetta and announces an additional shipment of wheat to that province, he is given much publicity for this act of charity. But the Chief Minister of Balochistan is never invited to come to Lahore and announce an additional supply of gas to Punjab, because we believe in Punjab that only we have the right to increase or decrease the supply of gas for us from Balochistan.

Instead of the colonial and bureaucratic approach, we need a more rational and realistic approach to tackle the problems confronting Balochistan and its people. By repeated military actions we may be able to occupy that land for a while, but we will not be able to win the hearts of its people.

It is time to heal their wounds, alleviate their sufferings, reunite their thousands of missing persons with their families, address their genuine grievances and remove the root causes of their feelings of hatred and disgust.

Besides this, it is the need of the hour that instead of working for the interests of others and fighting their wars on our own soil, our rulers should work independently in the best interest of our country and people. This is exactly what the 27 countries of South America at last did.

After several years of bloody conflicts and civil wars which they fought for American interests in their own countries, they told the Americans that they would no longer become their battlegrounds. The result is that with peace restored, their economies are growing at a much faster rate now. People belonging to 27 nationalities live in Iran and yet, it is a much more peaceful country than ours, only because its rulers give more importance to their country’s interests than to the American interests.

By: Orya Maqbool Jan

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.