April 7, 2012 brought heart rending news from the Giyari Sector of Siachen. A massive avalanche buried under it, 135 defenders of Pakistan and pushed the whole nation into a gloomy night of grief and sob. Although this merciless avalanche snatched our great men, fathers of many children, making many waives widows and leaving many mothers and sisters helpless, but it is highly hoped that their sacrifice will not go wasted and they will be obviously among the most blessed ones in the hereafter (Insha’Allah).
Siachen which literally means ‘black rose’ is located in the eastern ranges of Karakorum in Himalaya Mountains just east to the Line of Control (LOC) between the two South Asian arch-rivals, India and Pakistan. In Karachi Agreement of 29 July, 1949, and Simla Agreement of July 2, 1972, signed in the aftermath of 1948 and 1971 wars respectively, the issue of Siachen was not given due importance as it was deemed as a part of Pakistan. This was the reason that all the mountaineers and environmentalists used to take permission from Pakistani authority before commencing any of their expedition on Siachen.
Then, however, out of no way, a time came when Indian deliberately started interpreting the words of Karachi Agreement (KA) according to its choice and after about 35 years, in the year 1984, it covertly sent its troops to the icy heights of Siachen glacier under the code name of ‘Operation Maghoot.
When Pakistan received the reports of this Indian aggression, it was left with no other option but to follow the suit so that any further advancements of Indian troops might be clipped. From then the conflict on the roof of the world started. This pointless war has engulfed about 3000 Pakistani and nearly 5000 Indian troops. Surprisingly, on both sides, the climatic hazards like avalanches, crevasses, frostbites and glaciers’ sliding etc. have claimed more lives than by active armed combats. Presently, there are nearly 10,000 and 20,000 Indian and Pakistani troops stationed at the Siachen glacier.
It is of no doubt that sector Siachen is of minute strategic significance as said by the person who actually planned the Siachen operation Lt. General M.L. Chibber (r) who asserted in an interview as: ‘Siachen does not have any strategic significance’. The question arises if this occupation is so insignificant then why India is spending 5o million Rupees per day to maintain its troops on Siachen? It is only a tactic which India has been applying to keep on blowing severe dent to Pakistan’s fragile economy and to keep a great bulk of Pakistan’s forces engaged at this sector which are gnawing 15 million Rupees per day.
Occupation of Siachen by armed forces of both countries and their military activities has irreversible implications for environment and ecosystem of the glacier. The glacier has receded at a horrible pace in the last 20 years and is facing severe threat of climate change the consequences of which will be irrevocable. According to a former Indian Air martial: ‘Where Indian troops took 80 percent of their causalities from weather and human waste and war detritus produced by the two armies polluted crevasses and gullies that provide 70 percent of the water used in India and Pakistan.
This pointless war has engulfed about 3000 Pakistani and nearly 5000 Indian troops. Surprisingly, on both sides, the climatic hazards like avalanches, crevasses, frostbites and glaciers’ sliding etc. have claimed more lives than by active armed combats.
On June 12, 2005, Indian Primer Dr. Manmohan Singh, visited the Siachen and while assuring Indian troops of bringing them home, he said: ‘nobody fears any threat, there is no scope for any conflict and this place becomes an example of peaceful environment’ How long shall we allow such conditions to prevail (in Siachen)? Now the time has come for us to make efforts to convert this battlefield into a peace mountain. Later on he agreed with Pakistan in principle to withdraw forces and was very close to sign an agreement with Pakistan government but as revealed by wikileaks, the military establishment and Indian hawkish political parties did not let him step forward. At that time in 2006, the then Indian Chief of Army Staff, General JJ Singh vehemently declared: ‘We have conveyed our concerns and views to the government and we expect that the composite dialogue between the two countries will take care of all these concerns’ so these were actually some very serious ‘concerns’ of Indian military establishment which abstained Indian ‘Dove’ PM to end this aimless war. Then Wikileaks exposed this whole quagmire stating: ‘Every time India and Pakistan came very close to an agreement on the Siachen issue, the prime minister of the day would be forced to back out by the Indian defence establishment, the Congress Party hardliners and opposition leaders’.
The glacier has receded at a horrible pace in the last 20 years and is facing severe threat of climate change the consequences of which will be irrevocable.
As following the recent tragedy faced by Pakistan Army, Dr Singh offered assistance for relief operation which was a good gesture but it is highly suggestive that if the pain of this tragic event has really been felt, then this must act as an eye-opener for the leadership of both sides. What else both countries are waiting to lose? Moreover, after granting controversial MFN status to India and opening up of trade between the South Asian belligerents, it is expected that both states are moving towards normalization of relations. It is high times for India to abandon its obduracy and must reciprocate Pakistan’s unprecedented flexibility. This objective can be achieved by signing an agreement over withdrawal of forces to the pre 1984 period. Although the recent visit of Pakistan’s president Asif Ali Zardari to India on ‘private’ capac capacity was not seen as a breakthrough yet Dr. Sigh’s acceptance of his invitation for proposed visit to Pakistan, is undoubtedly a goods sign. Both states with the mediation of international community should strive to turn the glacier into ‘Peace Park’ and to end the war on the roof of the world as early as possible.